The October 21, 2025 matchup between the New Jersey Devils and the Toronto Maple Leafs at Scotiabank Arena brings together two Eastern Conference powerhouses built on speed, star power, and offensive creativity, making this one of the most anticipated early-season clashes on the NHL calendar. Both teams enter the game with high expectations and rosters loaded with top-tier talent, but they arrive at this point through different early-season narratives. The Devils come in riding a four-game winning streak, having rediscovered the form that made them one of the most dangerous transition teams in the league last year. Led by Jack Hughes, Jesper Bratt, and Timo Meier, New Jersey’s offense has been clicking at full throttle, averaging more than 3.5 goals per game while controlling possession at an elite rate. Their power play, fueled by the creativity of Hughes and the shot of Dougie Hamilton, has been operating above 25%, providing the lethal spark needed to finish off opponents in close games. The addition of young defensemen Luke Hughes and Simon Nemec has further solidified their blue line, giving the Devils a perfect blend of mobility, puck-moving skill, and defensive structure. Goaltending, which was once the team’s Achilles’ heel, has also stabilized early in the season, with Jake Allen and Nico Daws splitting time effectively and providing the kind of reliability that has often eluded New Jersey in recent years. On the other side, the Toronto Maple Leafs have started the season 3-1-1 at home and continue to be driven by their offensive superstars, namely Auston Matthews, William Nylander, and Mitch Marner. Matthews has once again established himself as a top goal-scorer, maintaining his trademark release and off-puck awareness that make him nearly impossible to contain.

Nylander has been on a tear as well, combining elite skating with confidence and precision in both creating and finishing plays. Captain John Tavares and Morgan Rielly provide veteran steadiness, while newcomers like Max Domi and Tyler Bertuzzi add grit and energy to the lineup. The Leafs’ power play remains one of the league’s most feared, converting at a rate near 30%, but their penalty kill has shown some inconsistency, particularly against high-movement offenses like New Jersey’s. Goaltending continues to be an area of scrutiny, with Ilya Samsonov and Anthony Stolarz splitting starts and both showing flashes of quality but lacking sustained dominance. Defensively, Toronto has been better structured under new head coach Craig Berube, but lapses in coverage and turnovers in transition remain issues against fast-paced opponents. This game will likely hinge on tempo control and special teams—New Jersey’s transition game and puck movement against Toronto’s offensive zone pressure and elite shooting talent. The Devils thrive on forcing turnovers in the neutral zone and turning them into quick-strike chances, while Toronto excels at cycling the puck and wearing down opponents with sustained offensive-zone time. For the Devils, the key will be maintaining discipline and avoiding unnecessary penalties that give Toronto’s power play room to operate. For the Leafs, containing Jack Hughes’ speed and neutralizing the Devils’ rush attack will be critical to dictating pace. From a betting perspective, this matchup shapes up as a close one; the Maple Leafs are likely slight home favorites, but New Jersey’s current form and superior five-on-five play make them an appealing underdog option. Expect an entertaining, high-scoring affair featuring end-to-end hockey, explosive offensive sequences, and elite individual performances from both teams. Ultimately, while Toronto’s home-ice advantage and star power could tilt the result, the Devils’ speed, cohesion, and confidence make them a legitimate threat to extend their winning streak and make another statement in their pursuit of Eastern Conference supremacy.

Get live NHL odds and precise AI NHL picks, predictions, and cover probabilities.