Islanders vs Penguins Prediction — AI Finds CAN'T MISS NHL Lines & Props (Oct 09)

Updated: 2025-10-07T03:31:50.923562ZBy Remi at Leans.AI — AI picks for ATS, ML, OU & props

The New York Islanders travel to Pittsburgh on October 9, 2025 to face the Penguins in a matchup that pits renewed depth against veteran grit. The Penguins open as modest favorites at home, but the line is expected to stay tight given the Islanders’ offseason reinforcements.

Get key insights, betting trends, and AI-powered predictions to help incorporate into your betting strategies.

AI Sports Betting Algorithm Remi

GAME INFO

Date: Oct 09, 2025

Start Time: 7:00 PM EST​

Venue: PPG Paints Arena​

Penguins Record: (1-0)

Islanders Record: (0-0)

OPENING ODDS

NYI Moneyline: -121

PIT Moneyline: +100

NYI Spread: -1.5

PIT Spread: +1.5

Over/Under: 5.5

NYI
Betting Trends

  • In recent seasons, the Islanders have had mixed success as road underdogs, covering perhaps 45–50 % of such games depending on matchup and travel fatigue.

PIT
Betting Trends

  • The Penguins historically perform well at home in ATS contexts, especially in early-season games when their top lines dominate in front of the crowd.

MATCHUP TRENDS

  • When these two teams meet in Pittsburgh, totals often lean under expectations — games tend to be tighter, more defensively inclined, especially early in the year before depth is fully tested.

NYI vs. PIT
Best Prop Bet

  • Remi's searched hard and found the best prop for this matchup: A. Lee under 2.5 Shots on Goal.

LIVE NHL ODDS

NHL ODDS COMPARISON

WANT MORE AI PICKS?

VAULT
VS. SPREAD
325-240
VAULT
NET UNITS
(INCL VIG)
+395.4
VAULT
NET PROFIT
(INCL VIG)
$100/UNIT
$39,540
EXECUTIVE
VS. SPREAD
1593-1364
EXECUTIVE
NET UNITS
(INCL VIG)
+371.9
EXECUTIVE
NET PROFIT
(INCL VIG)
$100/UNIT
$37,192

AI SPORTS PICK PRODUCTS

Create a Free Account

‘Create an Account’ to Get Remi’s Picks Today.

Remi Finds New Picks

Remi calculates the probability a team will cover the line.

Remi Works 24/7

Remi uses this probability to assign units to each pick.

Get Remi's AI Picks

Get Remi’s Top AI Sports Picks sent direct to your inbox.

New York vs Pittsburgh Prediction & Odds:
Free NHL Betting Insights for 10/9/25

The October 9, 2025 matchup between the New York Islanders and the Pittsburgh Penguins at PPG Paints Arena represents a battle of contrasting philosophies and timelines between two long-standing Metropolitan Division rivals. The Penguins, led by the enduring presence of Sidney Crosby and Evgeni Malkin, continue to balance their veteran core with new supporting pieces as they attempt to maximize what’s left of their championship window. After narrowly missing the postseason in recent campaigns, Pittsburgh retooled its lineup with an emphasis on depth scoring and defensive stability, seeking to avoid the late-season inconsistencies that have plagued them. On the other hand, the Islanders arrive in Pittsburgh looking to prove that their structured, defense-first system remains effective in an evolving, speed-driven league. Under head coach Patrick Roy, New York has leaned even more heavily into its identity as a disciplined, opportunistic group that wins by controlling tempo, minimizing turnovers, and capitalizing on mistakes. Mathew Barzal and Bo Horvat anchor the Islanders’ offensive attack, with Barzal’s playmaking vision and Horvat’s finishing touch giving New York a legitimate one-two punch capable of breaking open tight games. Their supporting forwards — Anders Lee, Brock Nelson, and Kyle Palmieri — bring veteran savvy and net-front toughness that align perfectly with the team’s grind-it-out style.

However, against Pittsburgh’s high-powered attack, the Islanders’ defense will be put to the test. Led by Adam Pelech, Ryan Pulock, and Noah Dobson, New York’s blue line must handle the Penguins’ speed in transition and prevent cross-seam passes that often lead to one-timers from the slot. Meanwhile, goaltender Ilya Sorokin remains the Islanders’ most valuable asset, a game-changing presence capable of stealing points with his elite reflexes and positional mastery. He will need to be sharp against a Penguins offense that thrives on sustained zone pressure and screens in front of the net. For Pittsburgh, much hinges on how well its retooled blue line manages New York’s forecheck. Kris Letang continues to quarterback the defense, but the Penguins’ younger defensemen must handle the Islanders’ cycle game and maintain clean exits to feed their forwards. Jake Guentzel’s scoring ability and Crosby’s unmatched hockey sense will test New York’s ability to match lines effectively, while Rickard Rakell’s creativity adds balance to Pittsburgh’s top-six forward group. In goal, Tristan Jarry faces the challenge of reestablishing consistency after uneven stretches in recent seasons; his ability to control rebounds and limit second-chance opportunities will be crucial against the Islanders’ relentless net-front play. Special teams could ultimately decide the outcome — the Penguins’ power play has long been a strength, but the Islanders’ penalty kill ranks among the most aggressive in the NHL, often turning defensive stands into counterattacks. Expect a tight, physical, low-scoring contest with extended stretches of neutral-zone chess and few clean rushes. The Penguins’ home-ice energy and experience give them a slight edge, but the Islanders’ structure, goaltending, and composure make them a dangerous underdog capable of spoiling any celebration in Pittsburgh.

New York Islanders NHL Preview

The New York Islanders enter their October 9, 2025 matchup against the Pittsburgh Penguins with a clear understanding of who they are — a disciplined, defensive-minded team that wins by controlling pace, protecting the slot, and relying on elite goaltending from Ilya Sorokin. Under head coach Patrick Roy, the Islanders have refined their identity into one built around structure, intensity, and patience. They rarely overwhelm opponents with offensive firepower, but their ability to stay organized and capitalize on mistakes makes them one of the most frustrating teams in the NHL to play against. Mathew Barzal remains the offensive engine, his skating and playmaking creating opportunities out of seemingly harmless situations. His chemistry with Bo Horvat continues to develop into one of the league’s more dynamic duos, blending Barzal’s creativity with Horvat’s quick release and strength around the crease. Behind them, veterans like Anders Lee and Brock Nelson provide scoring depth and leadership, while Kyle Palmieri and J.G. Pageau supply responsible two-way play and faceoff reliability that keep the Islanders competitive in tight, grind-it-out contests. New York’s defensive structure is anchored by Adam Pelech and Ryan Pulock, one of the league’s steadiest shutdown pairings, with Noah Dobson adding an offensive dimension from the blue line through his puck movement and power-play contributions.

Against Pittsburgh’s transition-heavy style, the Islanders must maintain their defensive layers and force the Penguins to the outside, preventing cross-ice feeds and second-chance rebounds. Sorokin, arguably one of the top five goaltenders in the NHL, will once again be their backbone. His ability to track the puck through traffic and steal momentum-shifting saves gives New York confidence even when pinned in its own zone. On special teams, the Islanders’ penalty kill will play a vital role, as Pittsburgh’s power play — led by Crosby and Letang — thrives on exploiting seams and moving the puck with surgical precision. New York’s PK unit, built on active sticks and aggressive pressure, must disrupt that rhythm early and often. Offensively, the Islanders will need to make the most of their opportunities; their power play, though inconsistent in recent seasons, has shown flashes of improvement with Dobson quarterbacking from the point and Barzal creating movement along the half wall. To win in Pittsburgh, New York must stick to its formula: disciplined forechecking, smart puck management, and strong net-front play. The Penguins will try to push pace and stretch the ice, but if the Islanders can slow the tempo, dominate faceoffs, and frustrate Pittsburgh’s attack through physical, grind-oriented hockey, they can tilt the game in their favor. Ultimately, this contest will come down to execution — if the Islanders’ veterans maintain composure under pressure and Sorokin delivers his usual brilliance, New York has every chance to escape PPG Paints Arena with two hard-earned points and an early-season statement victory against one of their most enduring rivals.

The New York Islanders travel to Pittsburgh on October 9, 2025 to face the Penguins in a matchup that pits renewed depth against veteran grit. The Penguins open as modest favorites at home, but the line is expected to stay tight given the Islanders’ offseason reinforcements. New York vs Pittsburgh AI Prediction: Free NHL Betting Insights for Oct 09. Credit USA TODAY/IMAGN

Credit: USA TODAY/IMAGN

Pittsburgh Penguins NHL Preview

The Pittsburgh Penguins return to PPG Paints Arena on October 9, 2025, to host the New York Islanders in a matchup that feels like a litmus test for how much gas remains in the tank of their legendary core. Led by Sidney Crosby, Evgeni Malkin, and Kris Letang — the trio that has defined a generation of Penguins hockey — Pittsburgh enters this season balancing nostalgia with a renewed sense of urgency. After narrowly missing the playoffs in recent campaigns, the Penguins have retooled their depth and defensive structure, surrounding their veteran stars with players who can complement their skill while alleviating some of the heavy minutes that have worn them down in recent years. Jake Guentzel remains Crosby’s ideal linemate, a relentless forechecker and one of the league’s most efficient finishers in tight spaces, while Rickard Rakell adds versatility and a scoring touch that gives the top six another dimension. Malkin still commands respect as a dynamic force capable of turning games on a single shift, though his role has evolved to focus more on puck protection and facilitating offensive flow through the neutral zone. The Penguins’ offseason efforts to improve their blue line and bottom-six depth will be put to the test against the Islanders’ structured system. Kris Letang continues to anchor the defense with his trademark mobility and calm under pressure, while younger defenders such as P.O. Joseph and Ryan Graves bring size and reliability to complement his style.

Defensively, Pittsburgh must be sharp in handling the Islanders’ forecheck and preventing extended shifts in their own zone, as New York thrives on grinding opponents down through sustained possession. Tristan Jarry will likely get the start in net, and his performance could define the night. Consistency has been the central question mark in his game, but when Jarry is composed and in rhythm, he’s capable of handling the heavy shot volume that often comes from the Islanders’ second and third lines. Special teams will play a critical role — the Penguins’ power play remains potent thanks to Crosby’s net-front awareness and Letang’s orchestration from the point, but execution will need to be crisp against an Islanders penalty kill that aggressively disrupts passing lanes. Pittsburgh’s penalty kill must also remain disciplined, staying compact and denying New York’s quick puck movement around the perimeter. At home, the Penguins will want to set the tone early by dictating pace and forcing the Islanders out of their comfort zone; quick transitions and sustained offensive pressure will be key to breaking through Sorokin’s world-class goaltending. Expect Pittsburgh to attack with purpose, cycling the puck deep and forcing the Islanders’ defense to chase. If they can win the battle in the neutral zone, establish net-front presence, and avoid defensive lapses, the Penguins’ combination of experience, crowd energy, and star power could be enough to edge out their rival in what promises to be a tightly contested divisional showdown.

New York vs. Pittsburgh Prop Picks (AI)

AI algorithm Remi is pouring through tons of stats on each player. In fact, anytime the Islanders and Penguins play there’s always several intriguing angles to key in on. Not to mention games played at PPG Paints Arena in Oct rarely follow normal, predictable patterns.
Remi's searched hard and found the best prop for this matchup: A. Lee under 2.5 Shots on Goal.

New York vs. Pittsburgh Prediction (AI)

Remi Robot Icon

Remi, our AI sports algorithm, has been pouring over tons of data from every simulation between the Islanders and Penguins and using recursive machine learning and cutting-edge AI to examine the data to a single cover probability.

The Algorithm has been most fixated on the unproportionally assigned emphasis knucklehead sportsbettors often put on player performance factors between a Islanders team going up against a possibly unhealthy Penguins team. Trends look to say the true game analytics might reflect a slight lean against one Vegas line specifically.

Unlock this in-depth AI prediction and all of our NHL AI picks for FREE now.

Below is our current AI New York vs Pittsburgh picks, computer picks Islanders vs Penguins, best bets, model edges, confidence ratings.

DATE GAME LEAN %WIN UNITS LEVEL
NHL 10/21 FLA@BOS GET FREE PICK NOW 7
NHL 10/21 CLB@DAL UNLOCK THIS PICK 1 INTEL Locked INTEL
NHL 10/21 SEA@WAS UNLOCK THIS PICK 0 INTEL Locked INTEL

These picks update as information changes—injury reports, weather, and market movement. Each line shows our model’s fair price, the edge versus the market, and a unit confidence rating (1–10). Odds and availability vary by sportsbook and time. Edges are computed against the listed price; value may change after line moves. Always shop for the best number. See the full NHL schedule

Islanders Betting Trends

In recent seasons, the Islanders have had mixed success as road underdogs, covering perhaps 45–50 % of such games depending on matchup and travel fatigue.

Penguins Betting Trends

The Penguins historically perform well at home in ATS contexts, especially in early-season games when their top lines dominate in front of the crowd.

Islanders vs. Penguins Matchup Trends

When these two teams meet in Pittsburgh, totals often lean under expectations — games tend to be tighter, more defensively inclined, especially early in the year before depth is fully tested.

New York vs. Pittsburgh Game Info

New York vs Pittsburgh starts on October 09, 2025 at 7:00 PM EST.

Spread: Pittsburgh +1.5
Moneyline: New York -121, Pittsburgh +100
Over/Under: 5.5

New York: (0-0)  |  Pittsburgh: (1-0)

Remi's searched hard and found the best prop for this matchup: A. Lee under 2.5 Shots on Goal.. Prices move—always shop for the best number.

When these two teams meet in Pittsburgh, totals often lean under expectations — games tend to be tighter, more defensively inclined, especially early in the year before depth is fully tested.

NYI trend: In recent seasons, the Islanders have had mixed success as road underdogs, covering perhaps 45–50 % of such games depending on matchup and travel fatigue.

PIT trend: The Penguins historically perform well at home in ATS contexts, especially in early-season games when their top lines dominate in front of the crowd.

See our latest NHL picks and odds pages for 2025 to compare prices before you bet.

New York vs. Pittsburgh Odds

AI algorithm Remi is pouring through tons of stats on each line. In fact, anytime the New York vs Pittsburgh trends are analyzed, there’s always several intriguing angles to key in on. Not to mention games played at extreme hostile environments almost always follow normal, predictable betting trends.

New York vs Pittsburgh Opening Odds

NYI Moneyline: -121
PIT Moneyline: +100
NYI Spread: -1.5
PIT Spread: +1.5
Over/Under: 5.5

New York vs Pittsburgh Live Odds

Games PTS ML SPR O/U
Oct 21, 2025 7:10PM EDT
San Jose Sharks
New York Islanders
10/21/25 7:10PM
Sharks
Islanders
+193
-222
+1.5 (-127)
-1.5 (+107)
O 6.5 (-111)
U 6.5 (-105)
Oct 21, 2025 7:10PM EDT
Vancouver Canucks
Pittsburgh Penguins
10/21/25 7:10PM
Canucks
Penguins
-109
-105
+1.5 (-270)
-1.5 (+222)
O 6 (-117)
U 6 (+101)
Oct 21, 2025 7:10PM EDT
Edmonton Oilers
Ottawa Senators
10/21/25 7:10PM
Oilers
Senators
-123
+109
-1.5 (+186)
+1.5 (-219)
O 6 (-105)
U 6 (-111)
Oct 21, 2025 7:10PM EDT
New Jersey Devils
Toronto Maple Leafs
10/21/25 7:10PM
Devils
Maple Leafs
+105
-119
+1.5 (-245)
-1.5 (+203)
O 5.5 (-116)
U 5.5 (+100)
Oct 21, 2025 7:10PM EDT
Seattle Kraken
Washington Capitals
10/21/25 7:10PM
Kraken
Capitals
+218
-252
+1.5 (-120)
-1.5 (+100)
O 6 (-110)
U 6 (-106)
Oct 21, 2025 7:40PM EDT
Florida Panthers
Boston Bruins
10/21/25 7:40PM
Panthers
Bruins
-155
+136
-1.5 (+170)
+1.5 (-195)
O 5.5 (-105)
U 5.5 (-111)
Oct 21, 2025 8:10PM EDT
Columbus Blue Jackets
Dallas Stars
10/21/25 8:10PM
Blue Jackets
Stars
+165
-189
+1.5 (-156)
-1.5 (+136)
O 6 (-125)
U 6 (+109)
Oct 21, 2025 8:10PM EDT
Los Angeles Kings
St Louis Blues
10/21/25 8:10PM
Kings
Blues
+114
-129
+1.5 (-225)
-1.5 (+189)
O 5.5 (-123)
U 5.5 (+107)
Oct 21, 2025 8:10PM EDT
Anaheim Ducks
Nashville Predators
10/21/25 8:10PM
Ducks
Predators
+117
-133
+1.5 (-217)
-1.5 (+185)
O 6 (-115)
U 6 (-101)
Oct 22, 2025 7:00PM EDT
Minnesota Wild
New Jersey Devils
10/22/25 7PM
Wild
Devils
+110
-130
+1.5 (-245)
-1.5 (+200)
O 5.5 (-125)
U 5.5 (+105)
Oct 22, 2025 7:30PM EDT
Detroit Red Wings
Buffalo Sabres
10/22/25 7:30PM
Red Wings
Sabres
+101
-115
+1.5 (-250)
-1.5 (+205)
O 6 (-104)
U 6 (-112)
Oct 22, 2025 8:30PM EDT
Montreal Canadiens
Calgary Flames
10/22/25 8:30PM
Canadiens
Flames
 
+113
 
+1.5 (-245)
O 5.5 (-128)
U 5.5 (+112)

NHL Past Picks

Remi—our in-house AI—prices every game and prop using multi-season priors, tempo/efficiency, injury/usage signals, and market movement.
We publish fair prices, recommended “buy-to” numbers, and confidence so you can bet prices, not teams.

This preview covers New York Islanders vs. Pittsburgh Penguins on October 09, 2025 at PPG Paints Arena.
Odds shown reflect widely available numbers and may update closer to kickoff.

Want more? Check live edges, player props, and line moves on our NHL odds pages, and compare prices before you place a bet.

    LEAN     %WIN     UNITS RESULT
MIN@WAS WAS -120 56.2% 3 WIN
WPG@PHI WPG -132 56.7% 3 WIN
NYR@TOR TOR -133 58.6% 4 WIN
CGY@UTA OVER 6 53.8% 3 LOSS
OTT@BUF OTT -108 53.1% 3 LOSS
FLA@DET AARON EKBLAD OVER 0.5 POINTS 54.0% 4 LOSS
LA@MIN LA -110 56.0% 5 LOSS
STL@VAN VAN -121 54.6% 4 LOSS
BUF@BOS BOS -114 54.9% 3 WIN
ANA@SEA SEA -125 54.2% 3 WIN
ANA@SEA TROY TERRY OVER 0.5 POINTS 53.3% 3 LOSS
BOS@WAS ALEX OVECHKIN TO SCORE A GOAL 41.4% 2 LOSS
FLA@EDM MATTHEW TKACHUK OVER 0.5 ASSTS 53.70% 3 WIN
FLA@EDM RYAN NUGENT-HOPKINS OVER 1.5 SHOTS ON GOAL 54.50% 4 LOSS
EDM@FLA ALEKSANDER BARKOV UNDER 11.5 FACEOFFS WON 53.00% 3 LOSS
EDM@FLA ALEKSANDER BARKOV UNDER 20.5 MINUTES ON THE ICE 54.00% 4 LOSS
EDM@DAL DAL -110 53.80% 3 LOSS
EDM@DAL DAL -125 56.70% 3 WIN
TOR@FLA MAX PACIORETTY UNDER 1.5 SHOTS ON GOAL 55.60% 5 LOSS
TOR@FLA WILLIAM NYLANDER UNDER 2.5 SHOTS ON GOAL 54.90% 4 LOSS
CAR@WAS WAS +140 47.70% 3 WIN
WPG@STL STL -110 54.80% 4 WIN
WPG@STL UNDER 5.5 55.70% 4 LOSS
CGY@LA MACKENZIE WEEGAR OVER 2.5 BLOCKS 53.10% 3 WIN
TB@NYR TB +110 49.80% 3 LOSS
SJ@VAN ALEXANDER GEORGIEV UNDER 24.5 SAVES 54.50% 4 LOSS
BUF@TB OVER 6.5 53.90% 3 WIN
NYI@PHI PHI -110 54.00% 3 WIN
LV@EDM RYAN NUGENT-HOPKINS OVER 1.5 SHOTS ON GOAL 53.00% 3 WIN
EDM@ANA OVER 6 54.20% 3 LOSS
CAR@BOS OVER 5.5 54.00% 3 WIN
NYR@NJ NJ -125 57.30% 4 WIN
COL@CLB OVER 6.5 53.80% 3 WIN
LA@UTA LA -125 54.70% 3 WIN
WPG@LV LV -120 54.80% 3 LOSS
MIN@NJ UNDER 5.5 53.80% 3 WIN
NSH@PHI PHI -120 55.00% 3 WIN
OTT@BUF OVER 6 54.00% 3 LOSS
CHI@SJ CHI +105 51.60% 3 LOSS
WAS@LA WAS +105 51.20% 3 LOSS
TB@CAR CAR -130 56.40% 3 WIN
NSH@BOS BOS -125 55.20% 3 LOSS
MIN@SEA SEA -120 54.60% 3 LOSS
SJ@TOR OVER 6 54.80% 3 LOSS
BUF@MON MON -110 54.70% 4 WIN
BOS@PIT PIT -120 54.90% 3 LOSS
LA@STL STL -110 53.70% 3 WIN
LA@DAL DAL -125 56.40% 4 WIN
PIT@PHI PHI -116 54.20% 3 WIN
DET@MIN MIN -115 54.20% 3 LOSS
MIN@DET DET -130 58.00% 3 LOSS