The Week 9 matchup between the Indianapolis Colts and the Pittsburgh Steelers on November 2, 2025, at Acrisure Stadium brings together two AFC teams on very different trajectories but with plenty at stake. The Colts, one of the league’s most balanced and explosive teams, enter at 7-1 and boast one of the NFL’s most efficient scoring offenses, averaging over 33 points per game with a top-three red-zone touchdown rate. Head coach Shane Steichen has this group operating with confidence, leveraging a dynamic combination of Jonathan Taylor’s ground dominance and Daniel Jones’ poise and play-action precision. Taylor continues to be a workhorse back, ranking among the league leaders in yards from scrimmage, while Jones has taken a major step forward under Steichen’s tutelage, showing control, accuracy, and command in both tempo and situational football. The offensive line, led by Quenton Nelson, has been exceptional at creating movement in the run game and protecting Jones, allowing the Colts to sustain long drives while also hitting on explosive plays. On the defensive side, Indianapolis has quietly built one of the NFL’s most disciplined units, allowing fewer than 15 points per game and ranking in the top 10 in both takeaways and third-down defense. The front seven, anchored by DeForest Buckner and linebacker Zaire Franklin, has dominated opponents at the line of scrimmage, while cornerback JuJu Brents and safety Julian Blackmon have solidified the secondary. Pittsburgh, meanwhile, enters at 4-3, a record that looks respectable on paper but conceals the turbulence beneath. Head coach Mike Tomlin has once again kept his team competitive, but the defense, long the backbone of the Steelers’ identity, has shown troubling cracks. Coordinator Teryl Austin’s unit has struggled with both tackling and coverage discipline, giving up six passing touchdowns in the past two weeks and ranking near the bottom of the league in red-zone stops.

The once-feared pass rush led by T.J. Watt remains dangerous, but opposing offenses have neutralized it by emphasizing quick passes and outside runs. Offensively, Aaron Rodgers has brought veteran leadership and accuracy but has been betrayed by an inconsistent offensive line and a running game that fails to complement the passing attack. Najee Harris and Jaylen Warren have had flashes of success, but neither has been able to sustain drives consistently, leaving Rodgers in frequent long-yardage situations. Pittsburgh’s receivers, particularly George Pickens and Diontae Johnson, will need to win one-on-one battles against a physical Colts secondary if the Steelers want to keep pace. From a betting perspective, Indianapolis enters this contest as one of the most profitable teams in football against the spread, covering in six of their first eight games. The Colts’ combination of efficiency and consistency has made them a reliable pick both at home and on the road. The Steelers, conversely, have struggled in that department, covering in just three of their last seven games at Acrisure Stadium, largely due to their offensive inconsistency and defensive regression. The total for this game sits around 50.5 points, reflecting expectations of a high-scoring contest fueled by Indianapolis’ explosive offense and Pittsburgh’s propensity to give up big plays. The key matchup will be whether the Steelers’ pass rush can disrupt Jones enough to force turnovers and short fields—something that has been the only reliable formula for Pittsburgh victories this season. If the Colts establish control early with Taylor and force the Steelers into a pass-heavy game script, their defense has the edge to seal the deal. On paper, all indicators favor Indianapolis, but as history shows, Pittsburgh under Tomlin rarely goes quietly, especially at home. This game will test whether the Colts’ emerging juggernaut can maintain its dominance or if the Steelers can once again find a way to grind out an upset through grit, defense, and situational savvy.

Get live NFL odds and precise AI NFL picks, predictions, and cover probabilities.