Pirates vs. Reds
Prediction, Odds & Props
Sep 23 | MLB AI Picks

Updated: 2025-09-21T03:31:50.923562ZBy Remi at Leans.AI — AI picks for ATS, ML, OU & props

The Pirates travel to Great American Ball Park to face the Reds as Cincinnati looks to cling to a Wild Card spot and Pittsburgh wraps up a long season with few external pressures. The Reds, at 80–76, are playing with more urgency, while the Pirates, at 67–89, are in a rebuilding mode but often put together competitive efforts that make them dangerous.

Get key insights, betting trends, and AI-powered predictions to help incorporate into your betting strategies.

AI Sports Betting Algorithm Remi

GAME INFO

Date: Sep 23, 2025

Start Time: 6:40 PM EST​

Venue: Great American Ball Park​

Reds Record: (80-76)

Pirates Record: (67-89)

OPENING ODDS

PIT Moneyline: +131

CIN Moneyline: -156

PIT Spread: +1.5

CIN Spread: -1.5

Over/Under: 8.5

PIT
Betting Trends

  • Pittsburgh has struggled versus the Reds in recent head-to-head betting lines, going 3-7 against the run line in their last 10 matchups, which suggests they often come up short of the spread even when games are closer than the moneyline suggests. Their form is spotty of late, which adds risk to backing them in away games where the home team has more at stake.

CIN
Betting Trends

  • The Reds, playing at home, have been better at covering modest spreads when the crowd is behind them, particularly late in the season when their Wild Card aspirations lean on home performances. Oddsmakers have frequently favored them by about -152 in this matchup, reflecting both their recent winning streaks and the perception of Pirates’ pitching depth challenges.

MATCHUP TRENDS

  • The over/under for this game is set around 8.5 runs, indicating expectations for moderate scoring. Reds vs. Pirates matchups historically have produced mixed results on totals, but the trend leans toward overs when both offenses are starting pitchers who allow extra baserunners or give up power. Also, Reds have shown in recent games the ability to string together wins with bullpen depth, while Pirates’ offense has had trouble getting going against top-home pitching. That gives a bit more value to Reds moneyline or Reds −1.5 if the price is reasonable, and perhaps even the total going over if few early miscues exist.

PIT vs. CIN
Best Prop Bet

  • Remi's searched hard and found the best prop for this matchup: N. Marte under 1.5 Total Bases.

LIVE MLB ODDS

MLB ODDS COMPARISON

WANT MORE AI PICKS?

VAULT
VS. SPREAD
310-227
VAULT
NET UNITS
(INCL VIG)
+390.9
VAULT
NET PROFIT
(INCL VIG)
$100/UNIT
$39,086
EXECUTIVE
VS. SPREAD
1564-1335
EXECUTIVE
NET UNITS
(INCL VIG)
+387.3
EXECUTIVE
NET PROFIT
(INCL VIG)
$100/UNIT
$38,728

AI SPORTS PICK PRODUCTS

Create a Free Account

‘Create an Account’ to Get Remi’s Picks Today.

Remi Finds New Picks

Remi calculates the probability a team will cover the line.

Remi Works 24/7

Remi uses this probability to assign units to each pick.

Get Remi's AI Picks

Get Remi’s Top AI Sports Picks sent direct to your inbox.

Pittsburgh vs Cincinnati Prediction & Odds:
Free MLB Betting Insights for 9/23/25

The September 23, 2025 matchup between the Pittsburgh Pirates and the Cincinnati Reds at Great American Ball Park is set up as one of those late-season games that pits two clubs at very different stages of their competitive windows, with the Reds entering the night at 80–76 and still clinging to hopes of locking down a Wild Card spot, while the Pirates sit at 67–89, well out of contention but looking to evaluate their young roster and finish the season with momentum they can carry into 2026. For Cincinnati, the stakes could not be clearer—dropping games at home against a rebuilding divisional rival would put them in a dangerous position in the standings, so manager David Bell will be urging his team to play with playoff-level urgency from the first pitch. The Reds’ offense has been streaky but dangerous, showing the ability to generate power in bunches with Elly De La Cruz, Spencer Steer, and Jonathan India driving the lineup, while role players have helped keep the chains moving with timely contact hitting. Their starting pitcher, Brady Singer, has the responsibility of keeping Pittsburgh’s lineup from gaining early confidence, which means attacking the strike zone, limiting walks, and avoiding the big inning that has often been the Pirates’ best path to surprising opponents.

On the Pittsburgh side, the Pirates’ season has been defined by inconsistency but also by flashes of promise, with younger players like Oneil Cruz showing glimpses of star potential and a roster that, while not yet ready to contend, has developed a scrappy identity that allows them to hang around longer than their record might suggest. Their starter, Johan Oviedo, must set the tone by keeping the Reds’ bats quiet early and preventing the Cincinnati crowd from getting into the game, because the energy of Great American Ball Park can be a real factor when the Reds are in playoff pursuit. The Pirates’ offense, often inconsistent, needs to take advantage of every opportunity with runners on base, because against a Reds bullpen that has improved late in the season, wasted chances will likely be the difference between an upset win and another loss. Defensively, Pittsburgh has to be sharp and avoid the kinds of miscues that give extra outs to a Cincinnati lineup that can put crooked numbers on the board quickly, while the Reds must also stay disciplined and avoid gifting free bases that let the Pirates linger into the late innings. From a betting perspective, Cincinnati is the clear favorite at home given their record and urgency, but they have not always dominated the Pirates against the spread, as Pittsburgh tends to keep games close even in losses, which creates potential value on the run line. The total, set around 8.5 runs, reflects the possibility of moderate scoring given both teams’ ability to hit for power and the fact that neither starter has been consistently dominant this season. Ultimately, this game will hinge on execution in the middle innings and bullpen performance late, with the Reds’ path to victory clear if Singer provides a quality start and their bats deliver timely hits, while the Pirates will try to play spoiler by leaning on youthful energy, opportunistic offense, and a nothing-to-lose mindset that has occasionally made them a thorn in the side of better opponents.

Pittsburgh Pirates MLB Preview

The Pittsburgh Pirates enter their September 23, 2025 matchup with the Cincinnati Reds at Great American Ball Park as clear underdogs, but they carry with them the freedom of having nothing left to lose and the motivation of young players eager to prove themselves against a divisional rival still in the postseason hunt. With a 67–89 record, the Pirates’ season has been long decided in terms of contention, but that doesn’t mean they lack incentive; late September games offer opportunities for their younger core to gain experience and for veterans to show leadership in high-energy environments. Offensively, Pittsburgh has shown flashes of potency, particularly when Oneil Cruz, Bryan Reynolds, and Ke’Bryan Hayes contribute simultaneously, giving the lineup balance between power, speed, and situational hitting. The key for the Pirates will be to avoid their common issue of stranding runners, as against a team like Cincinnati, wasted opportunities can quickly become the difference between stealing an upset and fading away. Their expected starter, Johan Oviedo, will carry the burden of keeping the game close early by pounding the strike zone, limiting walks, and avoiding the big inning that could let the Reds’ offense feed off the home crowd’s energy.

Oviedo has shown stretches of dominance but has also struggled with command, so his ability to stay composed and deliver quality innings will be pivotal in giving the Pirates a chance. The bullpen has been a mixed bag throughout the season, with some arms capable of shutting down innings but others prone to collapses, which means that any lead or tie entering the later frames will come with uncertainty. Defensively, Pittsburgh has improved in recent years but still cannot afford lapses, as errors or mental miscues against Cincinnati’s power-heavy lineup could quickly tilt momentum. From a betting perspective, the Pirates’ poor record against the spread in recent meetings with the Reds makes them a risky play, though their ability to keep games competitive even when overmatched suggests potential value on the run line if the pitching holds together. Their formula for an upset is straightforward but demanding: they must get a strong start from Oviedo, cash in scoring chances rather than leaving runners stranded, and play error-free baseball to avoid giving the Reds easy opportunities to put the game away. If their offense can generate early pressure and their bullpen can avoid imploding in the late innings, Pittsburgh has the tools to frustrate Cincinnati and possibly spoil their playoff push, but if they fall into their familiar patterns of inconsistency, this could quickly become another example of a rebuilding team simply outclassed by a contender with much more on the line.

The Pirates travel to Great American Ball Park to face the Reds as Cincinnati looks to cling to a Wild Card spot and Pittsburgh wraps up a long season with few external pressures. The Reds, at 80–76, are playing with more urgency, while the Pirates, at 67–89, are in a rebuilding mode but often put together competitive efforts that make them dangerous. Pittsburgh vs Cincinnati AI Prediction: Free MLB Betting Insights for Sep 23. Credit USA TODAY/IMAGN

Credit: USA TODAY/IMAGN

Cincinnati Reds MLB Preview

The Cincinnati Reds return to Great American Ball Park on September 23, 2025, carrying both the weight of expectation and the urgency of a postseason chase, as they sit at 80–76 and continue to fight for a Wild Card berth that has energized their fan base and raised the stakes of every game. Facing a struggling Pittsburgh Pirates squad with nothing but pride on the line, the Reds know this is a matchup they cannot afford to squander, and the pressure will be on to take care of business in front of their home crowd. Cincinnati’s offense has been its calling card in 2025, led by the electrifying Elly De La Cruz whose blend of speed and power has made him one of the most exciting young players in the league, while Spencer Steer, Jonathan India, and Christian Encarnacion-Strand have provided depth and timely hitting to give the lineup balance. For the Reds to secure this game, they will need early production, cashing in runners in scoring position rather than waiting for late-inning heroics, because putting Pittsburgh on its heels from the outset will allow the Reds to dictate tempo and conserve their bullpen for the games that follow. Their expected starter, Brady Singer, must embrace the responsibility of setting the tone by throwing strikes, avoiding free passes, and forcing the Pirates’ hitters into weak contact, as Pittsburgh has been at its most dangerous when gifted extra baserunners.

Singer has the ability to eat innings and hand a lead to a bullpen that has been more reliable in recent weeks, with closer Alexis Díaz continuing to establish himself as a trustworthy finisher in high-leverage situations. Defensively, Cincinnati will need to stay sharp, because mistakes in a game like this could breathe life into an underdog Pirates team looking to play spoiler, and the Reds cannot afford to lose focus with so much on the line. From a betting perspective, the Reds are favored not just because of their superior record but also due to their urgency and recent form at home, where they’ve done a solid job of covering modest spreads, particularly when facing divisional opponents. Their path to success lies in executing cleanly in all phases: putting runs on the board early, getting steady work from their starter, and trusting their bullpen to secure the final outs. The energy of the Cincinnati crowd should also play a role, as fans sense the importance of every pitch down the stretch and have created an atmosphere that feeds the players’ intensity. If the Reds can play to their potential, limit mistakes, and avoid underestimating a Pirates team with nothing to lose, they should be able to strengthen their grip on the Wild Card race and continue their march toward October, reinforcing their identity as one of the National League’s most exciting young contenders.

Pittsburgh vs. Cincinnati Prop Picks (AI)

AI algorithm Remi is pouring through loads of datapoints on each team. In fact, anytime the Pirates and Reds play there’s always several intriguing observations to key in on. Not to mention games played at Great American Ball Park in Sep almost always follow normal, predictable patterns.
Remi's searched hard and found the best prop for this matchup: N. Marte under 1.5 Total Bases.

Pittsburgh vs. Cincinnati Prediction (AI)

Remi Robot Icon

Remi, our AI sports genius, has been pouring over exorbitant amounts of data from every angle between the Pirates and Reds and using recursive machine learning and kick-ass AI to crunch the data to a single cover probability.

Oddly enough, we’ve seen the AI has been most focused on the growing factor knucklehead sportsbettors often put on player performance factors between a Pirates team going up against a possibly unhealthy Reds team. Trends look to say the true game analytics appear to reflect a slight lean against one Vegas line in particular.

Unlock this in-depth AI prediction and all of our MLB AI picks for FREE now.

Below is our current AI Pittsburgh vs Cincinnati picks, computer picks Pirates vs Reds, best bets, model edges, confidence ratings.

DATE GAME LEAN %WIN UNITS LEVEL
MLB 10/1 SD@CHC UNLOCK THIS PICK 4 INTEL Locked INTEL
MLB 10/1 SD@CHC UNLOCK THIS PICK 4 EXECUTIVE Locked EXECUTIVE
MLB 10/1 CIN@LAD UNLOCK THIS PICK 3 EXECUTIVE Locked EXECUTIVE
MLB 10/1 CIN@LAD UNLOCK THIS PICK 2 INTEL Locked INTEL
MLB 10/1 DET@CLE UNLOCK THIS PICK 2 INTEL Locked INTEL
MLB 10/1 DET@CLE UNLOCK THIS PICK 1 INTEL Locked INTEL
MLB 10/1 BOS@NYY UNLOCK THIS PICK 1 INTEL Locked INTEL
MLB 10/1 CIN@LAD GET FREE PICK NOW 1
MLB 10/1 BOS@NYY UNLOCK THIS PICK 0 INTEL Locked INTEL
MLB 10/1 BOS@NYY GET FREE PICK NOW 0

These picks update as information changes—injury reports, weather, and market movement. Each line shows our model’s fair price, the edge versus the market, and a unit confidence rating (1–10). Odds and availability vary by sportsbook and time. Edges are computed against the listed price; value may change after line moves. Always shop for the best number. See the full MLB schedule.

Pirates Betting Trends

Pittsburgh has struggled versus the Reds in recent head-to-head betting lines, going 3-7 against the run line in their last 10 matchups, which suggests they often come up short of the spread even when games are closer than the moneyline suggests. Their form is spotty of late, which adds risk to backing them in away games where the home team has more at stake.

Reds Betting Trends

The Reds, playing at home, have been better at covering modest spreads when the crowd is behind them, particularly late in the season when their Wild Card aspirations lean on home performances. Oddsmakers have frequently favored them by about -152 in this matchup, reflecting both their recent winning streaks and the perception of Pirates’ pitching depth challenges.

Pirates vs. Reds Matchup Trends

The over/under for this game is set around 8.5 runs, indicating expectations for moderate scoring. Reds vs. Pirates matchups historically have produced mixed results on totals, but the trend leans toward overs when both offenses are starting pitchers who allow extra baserunners or give up power. Also, Reds have shown in recent games the ability to string together wins with bullpen depth, while Pirates’ offense has had trouble getting going against top-home pitching. That gives a bit more value to Reds moneyline or Reds −1.5 if the price is reasonable, and perhaps even the total going over if few early miscues exist.

Pittsburgh vs. Cincinnati Game Info

Pittsburgh vs Cincinnati starts on September 23, 2025 at 6:40 PM EST.

Venue: Great American Ball Park.

Spread: Cincinnati -1.5
Moneyline: Pittsburgh +131, Cincinnati -156
Over/Under: 8.5

Pittsburgh: (67-89)  |  Cincinnati: (80-76)

Remi's searched hard and found the best prop for this matchup: N. Marte under 1.5 Total Bases.. Prices move—always shop for the best number.

The over/under for this game is set around 8.5 runs, indicating expectations for moderate scoring. Reds vs. Pirates matchups historically have produced mixed results on totals, but the trend leans toward overs when both offenses are starting pitchers who allow extra baserunners or give up power. Also, Reds have shown in recent games the ability to string together wins with bullpen depth, while Pirates’ offense has had trouble getting going against top-home pitching. That gives a bit more value to Reds moneyline or Reds −1.5 if the price is reasonable, and perhaps even the total going over if few early miscues exist.

PIT trend: Pittsburgh has struggled versus the Reds in recent head-to-head betting lines, going 3-7 against the run line in their last 10 matchups, which suggests they often come up short of the spread even when games are closer than the moneyline suggests. Their form is spotty of late, which adds risk to backing them in away games where the home team has more at stake.

CIN trend: The Reds, playing at home, have been better at covering modest spreads when the crowd is behind them, particularly late in the season when their Wild Card aspirations lean on home performances. Oddsmakers have frequently favored them by about -152 in this matchup, reflecting both their recent winning streaks and the perception of Pirates’ pitching depth challenges.

See our latest MLB picks and odds pages for 2025 to compare prices before you bet.

Pittsburgh vs. Cincinnati Odds

Remi is pouring through mountains of data points on each team. In fact, anytime the Pittsburgh vs Cincinnati trends are analyzed, there’s always several intriguing observations to key in on. Not to mention games played at extreme altitude seemingly never follow normal, predictable patterns.

Pittsburgh vs Cincinnati Opening Odds

PIT Moneyline: +131
CIN Moneyline: -156
PIT Spread: +1.5
CIN Spread: -1.5
Over/Under: 8.5

Pittsburgh vs Cincinnati Live Odds

Games PTS ML SPR O/U
Oct 2, 2025 3:08PM EDT
Detroit Tigers
Cleveland Guardians
10/2/25 3:08PM
Tigers
Guardians
-103
-120
-1.5 (+180)
+1.5 (-235)
O 7 (-108)
U 7 (-118)
Oct 2, 2025 5:08PM EDT
San Diego Padres
Chicago Cubs
10/2/25 5:08PM
Padres
Cubs
-104
-118
-1.5 (+175)
+1.5 (-230)
O 7.5 (-113)
U 7.5 (-113)
Oct 2, 2025 8:08PM EDT
Boston Red Sox
New York Yankees
10/2/25 8:08PM
Red Sox
Yankees
+140
-175
+1.5 (-175)
-1.5 (+133)
O 7.5 (-117)
U 7.5 (-109)
Oct 4, 2025 2:30PM EDT
Los Angeles Dodgers
Philadelphia Phillies
10/4/25 2:30PM
Dodgers
Phillies
+108
-131
pk
pk
Oct 4, 2025 5:09PM EDT
Los Angeles Dodgers
Philadelphia Phillies
10/4/25 5:09PM
Dodgers
Phillies
+114
-126
pk
pk
O 7 (-134)
U 7 (+117)

MLB Past Picks

Remi—our in-house AI—prices every game and prop using multi-season priors, tempo/efficiency, injury/usage signals, and market movement.
We publish fair prices, recommended “buy-to” numbers, and confidence so you can bet prices, not teams.

This preview covers Pittsburgh Pirates vs. Cincinnati Reds on September 23, 2025 at Great American Ball Park.
Odds shown reflect widely available numbers and may update closer to kickoff.

Want more? Check live edges, player props, and line moves on our MLB odds pages, and compare prices before you place a bet.

    LEAN     %WIN     UNITS RESULT
ARI@SD SD -131 57.3% 4 WIN
DET@BOS BOS -115 56.4% 5 WIN
NYM@CHC NYM -110 54.1% 3 WIN
HOU@ATH ATH +118 50.8% 4 WIN
NYM@CHC OVER 7 54.5% 3 WIN
STL@SF OVER 7.5 55.9% 5 LOSS
KC@LAA TYLER TOLBERT UNDER 1.5 BASES 54.4% 4 WIN
MIL@SD UNDER 9 54.7% 4 WIN
MIA@PHI KYLE SCHWARBER OVER 1.5 HITS+RUNS+RBIS 53.3% 3 WIN
WAS@NYM OVER 8.5 56.1% 6 LOSS
LAA@COL COL +108 50.5% 3 WIN
TOR@KC UNDER 9 54.7% 4 LOSS
SEA@KC KC +1.5 62.3% 5 LOSS
NYY@MIN OVER 9 55.1% 4 WIN
MIA@COL OVER 10.5 55.0% 4 WIN
MIA@COL AGUSTIN RAMIREZ OVER 1.5 HITS+RUNS+RBIS 54.3% 4 WIN
SEA@KC BOBBY WITT UNDER 0.5 SINGLES 54.4% 4 LOSS
PHI@LAD LAD -113 54.7% 4 LOSS
NYY@BOS OVER 7.5 54.3% 3 WIN
KC@PHI PHI -130 58.3% 4 WIN
LAD@SF OVER 7.5 54.7% 4 LOSS
NYM@PHI PHI -122 55.6% 4 WIN
KC@CLE KC -104 52.0% 3 WIN
CIN@SD JAKE CRONEWORTH OVER 0.5 HITS 53.1% 3 WIN
WAS@MIA MIA -123 55.2% 4 LOSS
LAA@KC UNDER 9.5 54.9% 3 WIN
TEX@ARI UNDER 9 54.2% 4 WIN
SF@COL UNDER 11.5 56.4% 6 LOSS
SF@COL RAFAEL DEVERS OVER 1.5 BASES 56.1% 6 WIN
MIA@WAS WAS -110 54.4% 4 WIN
NYM@DET OVER 8.5 54.5% 4 WIN
TEX@ARI UNDER 9.5 56.4% 6 WIN
TEX@ARI ALEJANDRO OSUNA UNDER 1.5 BASES 54.1% 4 LOSS
ATL@CHC CHC -116 55.1% 3 WIN
PHI@MIL OVER 8.5 55.0% 3 WIN
ARI@LAD SHOHEI OHTANI OVER 2.5 BASES 54.2% 4 WIN
SEA@CLE CLE +1.5 57.2% 3 WIN
CHC@SF CHC -105 54.1% 4 LOSS
NYY@CHW RYAN MCMAHON OVER 0.5 BASES 54.1% 4 WIN
PHI@NYM OVER 8.5 55.6% 4 LOSS
LAA@TEX LOGAN OHOPPE OVER 1.5 HITS+RUNS+RBIS 54.1% 4 LOSS
KC@CHW KC -109 54.2% 4 WIN
SD@SEA DYLAN CEASE OVER 16.5 OUTS 53.9% 3 LOSS
SD@SEA UNDER 8.5 54.4% 4 LOSS
MIN@TOR JOE RYAN UNDER 2.5 EARNED RUNS 54.1% 4 LOSS
SF@MIL MIL +100 54.0% 6 LOSS
TOR@MIA MIA +1.5 62.0% 6 WIN
CHC@LAA OVER 9.5 54.9% 4 LOSS
BOS@NYY CARLOS RODON UNDER 4.5 HITS ALLOWED 54.2% 4 WIN
KC@DET DET -115 56.1% 5 WIN
CHC@LAA LAA +1.5 57.6% 5 LOSS