The October 25, 2025 matchup between the Ball State Cardinals and the Northern Illinois Huskies at Huskie Stadium in DeKalb brings together two long-time MAC rivals looking to find consistency as they head into the heart of conference play. While both teams have endured rocky starts, the game represents a chance to stabilize their seasons, particularly for Northern Illinois, who will rely heavily on its defense to slow down a Ball State offense that has struggled to find its rhythm all year. The Cardinals, sitting at 3-4 under head coach Mike Neu, have experienced a frustrating campaign marked by offensive inefficiency and a lack of explosive plays. Ball State averages just 13.7 points per game, one of the lowest marks in the MAC, and produces 4.52 yards per play while converting only 31.7% of their third-down attempts. Quarterback Kiael Kelly has shown flashes of athleticism but remains inconsistent as a passer, throwing for under 1,000 yards through seven games with more interceptions than touchdowns. The offense has leaned on running back Marquez Cooper, who has been the team’s lone bright spot, averaging close to 4.0 yards per carry and providing Ball State with a physical presence between the tackles. Unfortunately, the offensive line’s struggles in protection have limited any sustained rhythm, forcing Kelly into too many unfavorable passing situations. Wideouts Malcolm Gillie and Eddie Wallace have provided occasional big plays, but the lack of consistent quarterback play has left the Cardinals’ aerial attack one-dimensional. On the defensive side, Ball State has given up over 31 points per game and 6.17 yards per play, which has placed immense pressure on an offense not built to play from behind. The defense, led by linebacker Clayton Coll and safety Malcolm Lee, has played hard but has been on the field far too long due to the team’s inability to extend drives. Northern Illinois, on the other hand, may have one of the MAC’s most misleading records at 1-5, as their defense has been among the best in the conference statistically.

The Huskies allow just 10.8 points per game and 4.21 yards per play, an impressive figure considering their offense’s ongoing inconsistency. Head coach Thomas Hammock’s team has prided itself on physical defense and strong fundamentals, with linebacker Daveren Rayner and defensive lineman Raishein Thomas anchoring a front seven that excels at stopping the run. Offensively, however, NIU has struggled to complement that defense, averaging only 17 points per game and converting just 27.5% on third downs. Quarterback Ethan Hampton has split time with Justin Lynch, but both have faced challenges sustaining drives, resulting in red-zone inefficiency and turnovers that have cost the Huskies winnable games. Running back Antario Brown remains the offensive focal point, averaging 4.3 yards per carry, but opposing defenses have keyed on him due to NIU’s limited passing threat. For Northern Illinois, this matchup offers an ideal opportunity to assert its defensive dominance against a Ball State offense that has been unable to finish drives. From a betting perspective, the Huskies’ elite defensive numbers make them an attractive pick to cover, especially at home, where their physicality tends to dictate pace. Ball State’s inability to protect the quarterback and move the chains consistently plays directly into NIU’s strengths. Expect a low-scoring, grind-it-out contest in which field position, turnovers, and special teams make the difference. While both teams will struggle to find offensive rhythm, Northern Illinois’ balance on defense and ability to control the line of scrimmage should ultimately tilt the game in their favor. In a classic MAC-style slugfest, NIU’s defense may once again carry the day, sealing a much-needed home victory in a game that could easily finish in the teens or low twenties.

Get live CFB odds and precise AI CFB picks, predictions, and cover probabilities.