The Holy War returns with fierce emotion and playoff implications as the Utah Utes travel to Provo to face the undefeated BYU Cougars on October 18, 2025, in one of college football’s most anticipated Week 8 matchups. Both programs have surged into national prominence, with Utah’s trademark physicality clashing against BYU’s balance and discipline under head coach Kalani Sitake. This rivalry has always been defined by toughness and execution, and this season is no different—Utah enters with one of the Pac-12’s most efficient defenses, while BYU boasts an offense that thrives on rhythm, tempo, and efficiency. The stakes are enormous: Utah looks to reassert control in a rivalry they’ve historically dominated, while BYU aims to validate its undefeated start and make a legitimate playoff statement in front of its home fans. For Utah, the game plan centers on reestablishing defensive dominance. The Utes’ front seven, anchored by Junior Tafuna and Van Fillinger, remains one of the most disruptive in the nation, consistently collapsing pockets and setting the tone against the run. Linebackers Karene Reid and Lander Barton have elevated the second level, giving the Utes a blend of speed and discipline that allows them to contain dual-threat quarterbacks like BYU’s Bear Bachmeier. The secondary, headlined by Cole Bishop and Zemaiah Vaughn, has improved in coverage discipline and tackling efficiency, two traits that will be critical against BYU’s deep receiving corps. Utah’s offense, however, has been a work in progress.

Quarterback Cam Rising’s leadership and experience have kept the unit steady, but inconsistency on early downs has hurt their ability to sustain drives. Running back Jaylon Glover brings power and vision to the ground attack, while tight end Brant Kuithe’s return has added a reliable target over the middle. Offensive coordinator Andy Ludwig will likely lean on play-action and misdirection to slow down BYU’s pursuit and create open looks for his playmakers. Meanwhile, BYU enters with supreme confidence and a clear identity on both sides of the ball. Bachmeier has matured rapidly within Sitake’s offense, pairing patience with precision, while running back LJ Martin has become the Cougars’ offensive heartbeat—his combination of physicality and burst has anchored a ground game averaging well over 180 rushing yards per contest. The BYU offensive line, featuring Connor Pay and Kingsley Suamataia, has provided stability and leverage at the point of attack, keeping defenses off balance. Defensively, BYU has quietly become one of the country’s most complete units, ranking among the top 15 in scoring defense and red-zone efficiency. Edge rusher Tyler Batty and linebacker Ben Bywater headline a front seven that thrives on discipline and gap integrity, traits that will be tested against Utah’s physical running style. The Cougars’ secondary, led by Jakob Robinson and Micah Harper, excels at taking away explosive plays while forcing opposing quarterbacks to settle for checkdowns. The chess match between Utah’s physical grind and BYU’s balance will likely determine the outcome. If Utah’s defense can contain the run and dictate tempo, they’ll keep things tight into the fourth quarter, where Kyle Whittingham’s teams usually excel. But if BYU’s offensive line wins the trenches and Bachmeier stays mistake-free, the Cougars could seize control of the rivalry for the first time in years. In a series defined by emotion, precision, and grit, this 2025 edition of the Holy War has all the makings of an instant classic.

Get live CFB odds and precise AI CFB picks, predictions, and cover probabilities.