The September 20, 2025, meeting between the SMU Mustangs and the TCU Horned Frogs is not just another nonconference game but the renewal of the Iron Skillet rivalry, a contest that carries extra weight in Texas football culture and often produces intense, unpredictable outcomes regardless of preseason expectations. TCU enters the matchup undefeated, having started the season with a commanding win over North Carolina in which they looked balanced and in control, followed by another comfortable victory that reinforced their ability to execute efficiently on both sides of the ball. Quarterback Josh Hoover has provided stability and accuracy in the passing game, while their ground attack, led by Kevorian Barnes before his recent injury, has been both explosive and versatile, making the Horned Frogs’ offense a multi-dimensional threat. Their defense has been equally impressive, limiting opponents to minimal scoring opportunities, generating pressure on quarterbacks, and forcing turnovers that have fueled short fields and easy points for the offense. SMU, on the other hand, comes in with more questions but also with the kind of offensive upside that makes them dangerous in a rivalry setting, as Rhett Lashlee’s system emphasizes speed, tempo, and the ability to stretch defenses vertically and horizontally.

The Mustangs’ quarterback play has been solid, with their receivers consistently finding space to create big plays, but defensive inconsistency has plagued them, with lapses that allow opponents to extend drives or capitalize on explosive opportunities. To succeed against TCU, SMU must establish rhythm quickly, avoid turnovers, and keep pace on the scoreboard to prevent TCU from grinding down the clock with their rushing attack. Historically, rivalry games like this one tend to be closer than the odds suggest, and with SMU already showing flashes of explosiveness this season and TCU carrying the pressure of being favored, bettors may see value in backing SMU to cover if the spread grows too wide. The over/under, projected in the mid-60s, may hinge on whether SMU’s defense can slow TCU enough to keep the game in the 30s or whether both teams’ offensive strengths push the total comfortably over. Momentum will be critical, as early turnovers or quick scores could swing the game drastically in either direction, and in a rivalry setting, the emotional intensity can either sharpen execution or lead to costly mistakes. Ultimately, TCU has the more complete roster, the home-field advantage at Amon G. Carter Stadium, and the recent form to justify being favored, but SMU has the offensive tools and rivalry motivation to make this a much tighter contest than a casual observer might expect, and the outcome will likely hinge on which team can impose its identity early and handle the intensity of four quarters in one of Texas’s most spirited college football rivalries.